Donate

The winner of the 2nd Stuart Hall Essay Prize is Harriet Hillier, for the essay “Choosing a Nation: Identity, Belonging, and Representation in International Sport”.

The winning essay was the unanimous selection of the judging panel composed of Catherine Hall, Jo Littler and Kennetta Hammond Perry. The judges remarked: “This essay applies Hall’s conjunctural method to read culture at the intersection of political, economic and ideological forces. The case study is of fencing as an international sport and the author applies their experience of it as a participant to discuss what it means to represent a nation at this time, in a post-Brexit world in which borders have become ever more problematic, where sport is transnational yet aims to figure as a key symbol of national unity, and athletes adopt strategic nationalities in order to gain funding enabling them to compete. The essay is beautifully written and engages throughout with different aspects of Hall’s thinking – put to work in relation to the specificity of now. The moment – it is argued – is one of both crisis and opportunity: it raises the question as to what kind of nation we want to be, and insists that the nation’s story can be retold. We appreciated its extrapolation of the hybrid histories of the sport, its grasp of the neoliberal dynamics shaping its present, and its deft threading through of personal experience to tell the story on multiple levels.”

Responding to the decision and reflecting on her experience writing the essay, Harriet Hillier stated: “I entered the prize mainly for the experience and for the opportunity to explore an idea I was genuinely interested in. It felt like a rare chance to think more deeply about something personal, so I didn’t expect anything from it. I’m therefore genuinely surprised and very grateful that the essay has been awarded first place. Writing the essay allowed me to engage with Stuart Hall’s ideas in a way that felt both intellectual and personal. His understanding of identity as something shaped, performed, and continually negotiated really resonated with my own experience of representing a nation in sport. What struck me most is how relevant his work remains today, particularly in conversations around belonging, equality, and who gets to represent a nation.”

The winner of the £2,000 prize was selected from a shortlist of six. The other shortlisted entrants were Sam Adlam, Finn Kim, Holly Nsiya Mangu, Junghee Yang and Mark Yin.

The judges acknowledged Finn Kim with an honourable mention for the essay “Studentification as Gentrification: The Articulation of PBSA, HMOs, and Urban Belonging in London”. They recognised the author’s blending of evocative prose and ethnographic experience with social and political analysis in the essay’s exploration of how spatial forms of student housing provided through private capital (PBSA) and houses in multiple occupation (HMO) structure everyday lives for the neoliberal world.

The judges also acknowledged Holly Nsiya Mangu with an honourable mention for the essay “Whose Heritage Gets Archived? Stuart Hall, Digital Preservation, and the Paradox of Protecting Buildings While Displacing Communities in Brixton”. They recognised the essay’s combined understanding of racialised and classed exclusions from official heritage narratives and its investigation of the potential for counter-projects offered by digital archiving and experimental VR projects.

A panel comprising current and former trustees of the Stuart Hall Foundation was also involved in the judging process, reading over 100 submissions to draw up the shortlist from which the winner was selected.

The winning essay is available to read on the Stuart Hall Foundation website here.


About the winner

Harriet Hillier is a second year undergraduate Music student at the University of Manchester and an international épée fencer representing Great Britain at U20, U23, and senior level. In 2025, she was awarded the Royal Philharmonic Society Young Classical Writers Prize. She previously performed with the National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain (2022–24) and has medalled at two U17 World Cups. She also represented Great Britain at the World University Games last year.


About the judges

Left to right: Catherine Hall, Jo Littler, Kennetta Hammond Perry

Catherine Hall is Emerita Professor of History and Chair of the Centre of the Study of the Legacies of British Slavery at UCL. Her books include Civilising Subjects (2002) Macaulay and Son (2012), with others, Legacies of British Slave-ownership (2014) and Lucky Valley: Edward Long and the history of racial capitalism (2024).

Jo Littler is Professor of Culture, Media and Social Analysis at Goldsmiths, University of London. Her books include Left Feminisms (2023); with The Care Collective, The Care Manifesto (2020); Against Meritocracy (2018); Radical Consumption (2008);and, with Roshi Naidoo, The Politics of Heritage (2005).

Kennetta Hammond Perry is an associate professor in history at Northwestern University. Her research examines Black diasporic communities and political formations shaped by and within the imperial borderings of Britain. Her publications include London Is The Place For Me: Black Britons, Citizenship and the Politics of Race (2016).

__

The Stuart Hall Essay Prize is funded in its first two editions by a private donation, which was given to the Foundation to support a prize for young writers. Read more about the project here.

Stay connected

Sign up to our newsletter for the latest news, events and opportunities: